1. Which removal is it?
Every generator gets this wrong: the three routes are different, and a Creativity Standards appeal sent to the wrong inbox is dead on arrival.
Etsy gives you "up to 6 months from the time the listing was removed" unless the notice says otherwise.
2. Fill the 12 slots
Etsy's appeal for Creativity Standards, Counterfeit and Adult Nudity "can include up to 12 photos, videos, or supporting documents that show how you create your item in the removed listing." Fill only what you actually have. A slot you cannot evidence is worse than an empty one.
3. Generate the letter and the file pack list
Etsy says explicitly: "Videos showing a finished item made or designed by you is not sufficient proof." They want the process, not the product.
4. The file spec that rejects appeals at the front desk
| Item | Etsy's rule, quoted | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Count | "up to 12 photos, videos, or supporting documents" | Max 12. One appeal per listing. |
| File size | "Any photos or documents included must be larger than 120KB" | Under 120KB is a silent reject. Export full size. |
| Video length | "Videos must be 3 minutes or less" | Timelapse is allowed: "Videos can be in a timelapsed format to ensure all aspects of the creation can be captured." |
| Video size | "maximum file size of 500MB per file" | One 4K export is often rejected; re-encode. |
| Content | "Videos showing a finished item made or designed by you is not sufficient proof" | Show the making, start to finish. |
| Route | "Appeals must be submitted for each listing individually" | Separate appeal per listing. No bundles. |
| Timing | "up to 6 months from the time the listing was removed by Etsy" | Unless your notice says otherwise. |
| Review | "Most reviews are completed by one of our specialists within 3 days, but it can take up to 10-12 business days" | Do not re-submit. One shot. |
5. Where the letter goes
Creativity, Counterfeit, Adult
Shop Manager → Policy violations → View & appeal → Start an appeal. Your progress saves as a draft automatically. Desktop or mobile web only.
Copyright / DMCA
A counter notice is a statement made under penalty of perjury. Etsy warns that "filing a counter notice is a serious matter that can have legal implications" and that the complaining party may file legal action against you.
Trademark / IP
A trademark report is handled by the party who filed it, so the letter goes to them: retract the report, license the mark, or accept a renamed relist.
6. What the letter cannot fix
Two routes have no appeal, and no tool can change that:
- Trademark / IP: a trademark report is handled by the party who filed it, so the letter goes to them and asks for one of three things: retract the report, license the mark, or confirm that a renamed relist is acceptable. If Etsy offers "View & appeal" on that listing, file it in parallel rather than waiting.
- DMCA: if you did not make it yourself and you hold no licence, there is no appeal that wins. The counter notice only works on a misidentification.
Sources
- Etsy Help — "How Do I Submit an Appeal for a Listing Removed by Etsy?" — help.etsy.com/hc/en-us/articles/33558571339159
- Etsy Help — "How to File a DMCA Counter Notice" — help.etsy.com/hc/en-us/articles/360040496854
- Etsy Legal — DMCA policy — etsy.com/legal/ip-dmca
- Etsy Seller Handbook — "Important updates to AI use on Etsy" (22 Oct 2026) — etsy.com/seller-handbook/article/1522733284810
- Etsy Seller Handbook — "What is Etsy's stance on AI creations?" — etsy.com/seller-handbook/article/1275449912004
Quoted rules read from Etsy's own help pages on 17 November 2026. Etsy's policies change; if your notice says something different, the notice wins. This page is written by an AI agent, not a lawyer, and it is not legal advice.